Dog Chew Toys Buying Guide

How We Picked

In the competitive market of dog chew toys, various factors dictate the best choices. We analyzed products based on durability, material safety, popularity among dog owners, and suitability for aggressive chewers. We also considered the variety of options available for different dog sizes and chewing needs. The inclusion of real flavors, ergonomic designs, and value packs further shaped our top picks, ensuring a diverse range to meet differing canine preferences.

Buying Guide / Decision Criteria

Durability

• Material Composition: Ensure the chew toy is made from sturdy materials like natural rubber or nylon, which withstand heavy chewing.
• Manufacturer Reputation: Opt for brands known for delivering high-quality, long-lasting products.

Safety

• Toxin-Free Ingredients: Look for chew toys made with safe, non-toxic materials to avoid health risks.
• Size Appropriateness: The toy should match your dog's size to prevent choking hazards.

Design Features

• Interactive Elements: Toys with treat-filling capabilities or erratic bounce increase playtime engagement.
• Ergonomic Design: Choose toys that are easy for dogs to hold and chew.

Variety and Flavor

• Flavor Options: Offering various flavors such as bacon or chicken can encourage dogs to chew longer.
• Chew Resistance: Look for toys designed specifically for aggressive chewers to maximize durability.

Ranked Picks

1. Benebone Medium 4-Pack Dog Toys for Aggressive Chewers

• Best for: Aggressive chewers looking for a durable option.
• Consider if: Your dog enjoys gnawing on bones and you want variety.
• Durability: Made from premium nylon; designed to last longer with heavy use.
• Flavor: Infused with real bacon flavor to keep your pup engaged.
• Variety: This pack offers multiple shapes to cater to different chewing styles.

The Benebone Medium 4-Pack is specially designed for medium-sized dogs that are intense chewers. Crafted with a focus on durability, these toys are made from high-quality nylon and feature real bacon flavor infusions that make them irresistible for dogs. The set includes various shapes, allowing for easy grip and different chewing experiences. Great for maintaining dental hygiene, their design encourages dogs to chew, not just bite. This pack is an excellent choice for keeping your dog entertained while also supporting healthy chewing behaviors. The Benebone team ensures that each toy is crafted under strict quality guidelines in the USA, providing peace of mind regarding safety. View details

2. Benebone Wishbone Durable Dog Chew Toy

• Best for: Dogs that prefer chew toys that are easy to hold.
• Consider if: You want a single, high-quality chew toy for your dog.
• Built for chewing: Its wishbone shape allows for easy gripping and chewing.
• Bacon Flavor: Delicious flavor that encourages longer playtime.
• Durable Construction: Designed to withstand aggressive chewing without breaking.

This Benebone Wishbone Chew Toy is ideal for dogs that love to chew and tug. The ergonomic design makes it suitable for a dog's bite, allowing them to enjoy it without frustration. Made from a tough, high-quality nylon, it is guaranteed to last extensively, making it a great investment for dog owners. Dogs are naturally drawn to the bacon flavor that is infused into the material, ensuring an enjoyable play experience. This toy also promotes dental health as dogs chew, scraping away plaque and tartar buildup while they enjoy their time with it. Investing in a durable and engaging toy like the Benebone Wishbone guarantees hours of fun and engagement for your dog. View details

3. KONG Classic Stuffable Dog Toy

• Best for: Active dogs that need mental stimulation.
• Consider if: Your dog enjoys treat-dispensing toys that require problem-solving.
• Variety of Fillings: Stuff with treats or peanut butter for added fun.
• Durability: Made from natural rubber that withstands heavy chewing.
• Erratic Bounce: Offers unpredictable movement that keeps dogs engaged.

The KONG Classic Stuffable Dog Toy is a versatile option for dogs that require both mental and physical stimulation. This iconic chew toy can be filled with various treats, keeping your dog occupied for longer periods. Made from durable natural rubber, the KONG withstands heavy chewing and promotes healthy chewing habits while satisfying a dog's instinct to chew. The erratic bounce adds a unique challenge that can keep your dog entertained for hours, making it an essential addition to your dog's playtime arsenal. Perfect for both fetch sessions and solo play, this toy's unique design allows for hours of healthy chewing and play. The KONG Classic is a favorite among dog owners due to its reliability and engaging features. View details

4. KONG Puppy Natural Teething Rubber Chew Toy

• Best for: Puppies that are teething.
• Consider if: You need a safe and gentle chew option for your young pup.
• Designed for Puppies: Soft rubber material soothes teething discomfort.
• Stuffable: Fill it with treats to encourage chewing and play.
• Engaging Play: Reinforces good chewing habits while providing entertainment.

This KONG Puppy Natural Teething Rubber Chew Toy caters specifically to puppies that are going through their teething phase. The softer rubber material is perfect for sensitive gums and helps soothe discomfort while encouraging healthy chewing habits. Additionally, it can be filled with treats, making it a necessary tool to keep your puppy engaged and occupied during playtime. Its ergonomic design is ideal for little mouths, allowing easy grip and manipulation. This toy not only supports teething but also helps develop a positive chewing instinct. It's a reliable choice for ensuring your puppy has a safe, engaging, and fun outlet for their natural chewing behavior. View details

5. Petstages Pupstages Cool Teething Stick

• Best for: Young puppies needing teething relief.
• Consider if: You prefer a toy that can be frozen for additional relief.
• Freezable Design: Helps soothe sore gums during the teething process.
• Durability: Built to withstand chewing without breaking apart.
• Encourages Healthy Chewing: Supports good oral hygiene by keeping teeth clean.

The Petstages Pupstages Cool Teething Stick is an innovative toy specifically designed for puppies. This chew toy can be placed in the freezer, providing a cooling sensation that helps alleviate teething pain for young pups. The durability of the material ensures it can withstand chewing without falling apart, while the unique shape promotes healthy chewing habits. This toy also doubles as a means to encourage good oral hygiene, making it perfect for puppies aged 0-6 months. The cool sensation provides instant relief, offering comfort while also keeping your puppy entertained. Easy to hold and engaging, the Pupstages Cool Teething Stick is an essential tool for any puppy owner. View details

6. Benebone Puppy 2-Pack Dental Chew/Wishbone

• Best for: Puppies needing dental care and entertainment.
• Consider if: You want a value pack with two options.
• Flavor Infusion: Made with real flavors for engagement.
• Dental Health: Specially designed to promote teeth cleaning during play.
• Durable Construction: Made from tough materials to withstand chewing.

The Benebone Puppy 2-Pack offers a fantastic solution for puppy owners looking to support dental health while providing entertainment. With two chew toys designed with real flavors, dogs are encouraged to chew longer, helping them maintain their dental hygiene. These toys are constructed with durable materials, ensuring they can handle even the most aggressive chewers. Their unique shapes cater to a puppy's natural instinct to chew, facilitating healthy chewing behavior. The added benefit of dental care ensures that while puppies are enjoying their chew time, they are also working towards keeping their teeth clean, further enhancing their playtime experience. View details

7. Nylabone Original Bone Power Chew Toy Value Pack

• Best for: Fur babies who love variety in flavors.
• Consider if: You want a selection of toys for different chewing preferences.
• Flavor Variety: Includes chicken, bacon, and peanut butter options.
• Durable Material: Built to withstand aggressive chewing.
• Value Pack: Comes with three different toys for varied experiences.

The Nylabone Original Bone Power Chew Toy Value Pack caters to dogs by providing multiple flavors, ensuring they never get bored. This value pack includes toys in chicken, bacon, and peanut butter flavors, all made with durable materials that can withstand strong chewing. This pack allows for versatility in playtime, offering a variety of textures and tastes to keep dogs engaged and happy. The design promotes good dental health as dogs chew, helping to prevent plaque and tartar buildup while also satisfying their urge to chew. For dog owners looking for long-lasting entertainment options, this is an excellent all-in-one purchase that satisfies both flavors and durability. View details

8. SPOT Bam-Bones Plus T Bone

• Best for: Moderate to aggressive chewers.
• Consider if: You want a combination of bamboo fiber and nylon for durability.
• Non-Splintering: Designed not to splinter during chewing.
• Flavor Appeal: Infused with a long-lasting beef flavor.
• Lightweight Design: Easy for dogs to carry and chew on.

The SPOT Bam-Bones Plus T Bone is an innovative toy tailored for aggressive chewers. Composed of bamboo fiber and nylon, this toy offers durability without compromising on safety, as it's engineered to be non-splintering. The enticing long-lasting beef flavor keeps dogs engaged and encourages longer chewing sessions. Its lightweight design makes it easy for dogs to carry around, ensuring they can munch on it comfortably wherever they go. This chew toy is a thoughtful option for dog owners who understand the importance of keeping their pets engaged with a reliable and safe option that meets their chewing needs. View details

9. Frienhund Tough Dog Toys 3 Pack

• Best for: Large breeds that are aggressive chewers.
• Consider if: You're looking for multiple indestructible options.
• Indestructibility: Specifically designed for hard-chewing dogs.
• Flavor Variety: Bacon-flavored to attract dogs' interest.
• Engagement: Keeps dogs busy, reducing boredom and destructive behaviors.

The Frienhund Tough Dog Toys 3 Pack caters specifically to large dogs that are powerful chewers. This set includes three durable toys designed to withstand intensive chewing without breaking apart. The bacon flavor ensures that these toys remain appealing and engaging for long periods, reducing the chances of dogs looking for alternative chewing options around the house. Their unique construction allows for extended durability, making them a smart investment for owners of aggressive chewers who require toys that can endure heavy use. With multiple options in one pack, it also helps keep dogs engaged and mentally stimulated, reducing behavioral issues associated with boredom. View details

10. KONG Ring

• Best for: Dogs that need dental care while chewing.
• Consider if: You want a ring that supports healthy chewing habits.
• Dental Health Support: Promotes good oral hygiene through chewing.
• Versatility: Suitable for fetch and chew playtime.
• Durable Construction: Made with KONG's tough rubber for strong chewers.

The KONG Ring is another solid choice for dog owners aiming to support their pet's dental health. Designed to promote healthy chewing habits, it can withstand the rigors of intense chewing. The durable construction ensures that it lasts while providing various use scenarios, from fetching to chewing. Ideal for both indoor and outdoor play, it's easy to clean and maintain. Dogs are naturally drawn to their shapes and textures, making them an enticing option for many breeds. Owners can feel confident incorporating the KONG Ring into their dog's play routine, knowing that it delivers satisfaction and promotes good health. View details

11. Multipet Original Loofa Dog Plush Toy

• Best for: Gentle chewers or dogs needing comfort.
• Consider if: You want a soft toy for cuddling and light chewing.
• Soft Material: Comfortable for dogs to hug and chew gently.
• Squeaky Fun: Features a squeaker to engage dogs during play.
• Adorable Design: A playful look that appeals to dogs' playful nature.

The Multipet Original Loofa Dog Plush Toy is an enjoyable and comforting option for dogs who prefer softer toys. The plush exterior is gentle on a dog's teeth, making it suitable for gentle chewers or those who enjoy soft cuddles. With its squeaky interior, this toy provides an enticing auditory experience that can capture a dog's attention during playtimes, making it ideal for fetch or cuddling alike. The playful loofah design adds a whimsical touch that many dogs adore. While it may not be the best choice for aggressive chewers, its appeal lies in its comfort, making it a staple in many pet households. View details

12. WinTour Tough Dog Toys for Aggressive Chewers

• Best for: Medium to large breeds that need robust toys.
• Consider if: You're looking for squeaky toys with added durability.
• Indestructible Design: Engineered with tough materials to withstand aggressive chewing.
• Dental Cleaning: The act of chewing supports better oral hygiene.
• Engaging Features: Keeps dogs busy while playing.

The WinTour Tough Dog Toys for Aggressive Chewers are designed specifically for strong and active dogs. Their indestructible design ensures they can withstand heavy chewing sessions without damage. These toys feature squeaky elements that appeal to dogs, enhancing interactive play that reduces boredom. Additionally, the material supports dental health, helping clean teeth and freshen breath as dogs chew. Ideal for both indoor and outdoor use, these robust toys cater to medium and large breeds, ensuring that even the most powerful chewers have a reliable option to satisfy their chewing instincts. View details

Who Should Buy What

Understanding what type of dog chew toy is best for your pet can significantly improve their play experience:

• Benebone Medium 4-Pack Dog Toys - Best for aggressive chewers of medium breeds.
• Benebone Wishbone - Ideal for dogs that prefer easily gripped designs.
• KONG Classic - Great for keeping active dogs mentally stimulated.
• Petstages Pupstages - For young puppies that need gentle teething relief.
• Benebone Puppy 2-Pack - Excellent for promoting dental care in puppies.
• Nylabone Original Bone - Suitable for dogs who enjoy varied flavors and textures.
• SPOT Bam-Bones Plus T Bone - Perfect for moderate to aggressive chewers.
• Frienhund Tough Dog Toys - Great for large breeds with strong chewing tendencies.
• KONG Ring - Supports dental health while offering engaging play.
• Multipet Loofa Plush Toy - Best suited for gentle chewers or dogs needing comfort.
• WinTour Tough Dog Toys - Ideal for large breeds that require durability and fun.

FAQs

• What are the best material options for chew toys? The best options are durable materials like natural rubber and nylon, which are specifically designed to withstand strong chewing.
• How can I determine if a chew toy is safe? Look for toys made from non-toxic materials and ensure that the size is appropriate for your dog to prevent choking hazards.
• Can chew toys help with dental health? Yes, many chew toys are designed to promote dental hygiene by cleaning teeth and freshening breath as dogs chew.
• How often should I replace my dog's chew toys? It's advisable to replace chew toys when they become worn or damaged to ensure your dog's safety and continued engagement.
• What if my dog doesn't like the toy? Each dog has its preferences; try different textures and flavors to find one that appeals to your dog.
• Are plush toys suitable for aggressive chewers? Generally, plush toys may not hold up well against aggressive chewers. Consider more durable materials if your dog chews heavily.
• Is there a difference between puppy and adult toys? Yes, puppy toys are often softer and made for teething, while adult toys are designed for durability and tough chewing.
• How can I clean chew toys? Many rubber and nylon chew toys can be cleaned with soap and water. Always check for cleaning instructions.

Final Recommendation + Checklist

Choosing the right chew toy for your dog is essential for their physical and mental well-being. Here's a quick checklist:

• Consider your dog's size and chewing strength.
• Look for durable, non-toxic materials.
• Focus on designs that encourage healthy chewing habits.
• Choose toys that offer flavor and interactive elements, if applicable.
• Regularly inspect toys for wear and replace them when necessary.

Investing in the right chew toy ensures a safe, enjoyable, and rewarding experience for your furry friend.